How we plan to use MoneyWell
The question: Are there any gotchas in the approach outlined below?
We've just started working with MoneyWell. I'd like to describe our situation and how we plan to use MoneyWell.
My wife and I are retired and live in Mexico. We are living from our savings.
We do not plan to manage our bank accounts with MoneyWell. In MoneyWell we will use a single virtual account called "Money". We will manage our real bank and investment accounts using the website of each institution.
We know how much money we can afford to withdraw from savings each year. We plan to "deposit" that full amount as Income in our Money account the first day of each budget year. Subsequent allocations to our expense buckets will flow from that initial deposit for the rest of the year.
Because Mexico is a cash economy, and because we do not want to (and realistically would not) write down every trip to the market, etc., we are not going to track small cash expenditures. Instead, our Spending Plan will include a large monthly amount in the Cash Expenditure expense bucket. Every time we make an ATM withdrawal, we will count it as an expense against that bucket.
Other than our Cash Expenditure bucket, we are going to create expense buckets for purchases that we pay directly from our bank accounts, e.g., our phone bill, and very large outlays, e.g., our annual car insurance, travel. We'll also have a bucket called "Unexpected" for big surprises such as major car repairs. We will not include any Planned amount for this bucket, but will build enough buffer into our Cash Expenditure bucket to cover (we hope) most Unexpected expenses.
We'll also include a monthly allowance for each of us in the spending plan. We think this is important, because it takes a lot of discretionary spending on expensive items out of the household spending plan. If I want a new lens for my camera, I know that I have to save from my allowance until I can afford it.
I realize that what we plan to do is not by the book, especially not tracking small cash purchases. However, we have been doing something similar with Quicken for a while now, and it has worked well.
I welcome your comments.
Jeff
Comments are currently closed for this discussion. You can start a new one.
Support Staff 2 Posted by Kevin Hoctor on 20 Jun, 2009 08:14 PM
Hi Jeff,
This sounds fine. I would still transfer all cash withdrawals from your savings account to the Cash Account in MoneyWell so you can track your spending. You may not want to track all your minor expenditures but you probably should group and track them as money spent and assign each to a bucket.
You can still allocate income to expense buckets by assigning the deposit transaction to your accounts that are used to pay bills and allocating that money. Use this to also fill buckets that will be used annually or semi-annually for larger purchases or payments.
I hope this helps.
3 Posted by jeffcharles on 21 Jun, 2009 07:49 PM
Kevin,
Thanks for your response.
Our intent is to pay no attention to our real accounts in MoneyWell. We'll use only the virtual money-flow layer. I believe that this approach is going to work well for us.
There are a few minor enhancements that I'd like to see having to do with annual views and a summary total of all expense bucket. I will post those in the Suggestions category.
Jeff